|
Post by starandchlorisse on Jun 8, 2016 18:50:11 GMT
Hi In general
1. Is it Ok to have an air gap between the Q7D and the wall? Or they should be mounted mounting flush to the wall.?
Is there any difference? I have build bass traps as bases to place the diffusers on and I have them on purpose one foot away from the garage door which is my rear wall.
2. Also if they have to be flush to the wall does it matter that there will be one or 2 inches gap ( because of the structure of the garage door and window glass, the glass is a little inside the door - so the surface is not totally straight)
- this will influence the acoustic performance ?
Best
many thanks
|
|
jhbrandt
New Member
Isolation & Acoustics Design
Posts: 8
|
Post by jhbrandt on Jun 9, 2016 3:34:03 GMT
Either way can work. I assume that you are talking about a diffusor mounted/embedded in the treatment on the back wall, right?
When a diffusor is IN the treatment, you should adjust the placement so that the diffusor is only sticking out or the treatment no more than 2" or so. This can give you a bit of space behind for trapping. The trapping can/will work in LF even though it is not 'visible' from the front of the diffusor.
If you mount a diffusor on the wall w/o treatment and there is an empty gap behind it - depending on the mass of the diffusor - you CAN create a resonant pocket that might produce errors due to the resonance... similar to a wall partition that is not filled with insulation.
I hope this helps.
Cheers, John
|
|
|
Post by starandchlorisse on Jun 9, 2016 15:21:32 GMT
Thank you I also see Real traps diffusers to be placed away from the wall - most likely for this reason ----cannot get rid of this icon- sorry
they have fiberglass on the back and it works for low frequencies absorption also ...
So
-my diffusers cannot be in the treatment but I could do the following :
On the rear wall -behind the engineer s back -
/ One foot or less or more from the wall - bass traps / 2 inches air gap ? / Diffuser almost same size as the bass traps - maybe the bass traps are slightly larger. All these centered vertically at ears height - ------------ This will be equally effective ?
|
|
jhbrandt
New Member
Isolation & Acoustics Design
Posts: 8
|
Post by jhbrandt on Jun 10, 2016 8:20:38 GMT
Thank you I also see Real traps diffusers to be placed away from the wall - most likely for this reason ----cannot get rid of this icon- sorry
they have fiberglass on the back and it works for low frequencies absorption also ...
So
-my diffusers cannot be in the treatment but I could do the following :
On the rear wall -behind the engineer s back -
/ One foot or less or more from the wall - bass traps / 2 inches air gap ? / Diffuser almost same size as the bass traps - maybe the bass traps are slightly larger. All these centered vertically at ears height - ------------ This will be equally effective ? YES, it should be.. Ethan, of course, will have more particular information about HIS diffusors. Cheers, John
|
|
|
Post by Ethan Winer on Jun 10, 2016 16:57:01 GMT
I also see Real traps diffusers to be placed away from the wall - most likely for this reason Yes, RealTraps Diffusers are made of rigid fiberglass, so an air space behind increases the bass trapping. --Ethan
|
|
|
Post by starandchlorisse on Dec 19, 2016 6:03:09 GMT
just a complimentary question on a planned change. This is the set up in my control room now. On the rear wall -behind the engineer s back - / One foot or less or more from the wall - bass traps / 2 inches air gap / Diffuser almost same size as the bass traps - maybe the bass traps are slightly larger. All these centered vertically at ears height - There are bass traps on the corners and celling - and the diffusers are sitting on bass traps as well. ------------ I was wondering - if I modified the set up- If I increase the distance behind the bass traps and the diffusers to 4 feet or something so I can be able to build bookshelves on the back wall so I can walk comfortably there - it will be ok? I have enough space - 23 feet is the length of my room and if I add the bookshelves behind the mixing spot will be about 6 feet and 8 inches away from the diffusers. From my readings here - I think that will be ok - but I just wanted to double check with you. Ethan . Hexpa John Rock ? Many thanks. This is a pic with the current set up - I had good results measurements so far. The orange line approximately shows what I want to do to be able to build bookshelves behind the diffusers.
|
|
|
Post by cyclecamper on Dec 19, 2016 20:56:25 GMT
So you want to relocate absorbers and diffusors in order to create a pedestrian passageway behind, between the diffusors and the grage door as back wall.
I don't know enough about Ethan's specific Q7D yet to be as much help as he would. It looks like you're already pretty involved! I'm still learning my way around. Everything I have to add may be wrong if his diffusors are open-back and really absorb much...in which case the main room would benefit from the space behind and absorb any reverberations in that passageway too.
Most absorbers are likely to work better when moved farther from the wall, assuming the absorbers do not have sealed backs. If the backs are sealed the characteristics of that partition become involved.
The diffusors have two considerations: - The properties of the bigger new "hallway" chamber behind them that this will create, and the dimensions of the openings from this new hallway to the main room. This can be addressed with additional absorption within that chamber, hopefully without interfering with pedestrian traffic. The difficult goal would be to turn this problem area into a tuned absorber. You might need to hang futons on the walls and walk on one in order to actually achieve that. - The other problem is a side effect: making that area larger makes the main area smaller. Depending on the lowest frequency they intend to diffuse, there is a preferred minimum distance the listener or mic should be from a diffusor. So moving the diffusor nearer the listener is sub-optimal. But that's really a special case of something more fundamental: for mid & high frequencies, this is making the room acoustically smaller when the objective is the opposite. Making the main space smaller will not help you get rid of those early reflections <10ms and can raise the frequency of the lowest modes which are related to the length of the room. The diffusors are not going to work that low unless they are some hybrid 'diffsorbers' so you also have to consider the dimension of the step you are creating in the back wall of the main room, and whether the modes with and without the step will reinforce (frequencies of modes too close).
In general, I would recommend against making the main space smaller, especially not moving the diffusors closer to the listener. Assuming this is some sort of LEDE room, and you really need that passageway and have to make the main space smaller, maybe you could turn it around. Open-back absorbers will work to lower frequencies with the additional space behind, much more than the diffusors. It sounds like you will be far enough from the diffusors, but more is always better IMHO. You have one good dimension, why not keep it? How do the main modes stack up now, are they a problem that might improve by moving the diffusors? How difficult is it to do, and do you have any room measurement tools?
Look at it this way. Ideally, the area directly in front of diffusors is not really usable for much. It's an ideal location for an open passageway walking area IN FRONT of the diffusors. I hate fireplaces because you can't place furniture in front of them or they start on fire, so I design rooms with a fireplace to use that space for pedestrian traffic flow, just because it's not very useful for anything else. I'm starting to regard the space in a room in front of diffusors similarly: not useful for much else, so it might as well be the access pathway for foot traffic patterns. I think you're much better off putting the diffusors close to the garage door. And I'd probably install a garage door insulation kit since it's affordable and easy.
|
|
|
Post by starandchlorisse on Dec 19, 2016 22:02:47 GMT
The diffusers you see in the pic have bass traps behind them and I don't know if you can tell but the there are bass traps on the corners and celling treating somehow the already little chamber with good results. I m trying to figure out if I increase the space behind it will make things worse.. the-audio-expert.freeforums.net/thread/37/garage-turned-control-electronic-production?page=2But I hear the diffusers distance problem from the mixing spot and making the room smaller ..
|
|