Post by Hexspa on Feb 25, 2016 15:29:53 GMT
Hello Audio Experts. My name is Michael and this is my first post. While my initial theory has been debunked it has been requested that I post my query here so here it is:
Hi Mr. Winer. Hope you're well. Wondering if you've seen this video about 192kHz sample rates. www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_wxRGiBoJg
Presently I'm unsure of your stance on this but the gentleman brings up an interesting point: timing and distance become the focus above 44.1kHz sampling rather than pitch.
Inspired by you I did a little test on my MOTU ultralite mk3 and, hardware quality notwithstanding, I found a perceptible difference among the sample rates.
I just thought you might appreciate the perspective if you weren't already familiar. Thanks!
PS - if you'd like I can give you a drop box link to my files.
-----
(response follows edited):
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIQ9IXSUzuM
-----
me again:
I've seen that vid and even have shared it. Thanks for pointing out that specific section though. I'm clicking around your forum but the link didn't send me to any thread. I would definitely like to hear what you have to say about sample rates though.
I've seen that vid and even have shared it. Thanks for pointing out that specific section though. I'm clicking around your forum but the link didn't send me to any thread. I would definitely like to hear what you have to say about sample rates though.
All I can say is that listening to these files I recorded there's a difference in sound among the sample rates. This is true regardless of what I set my audio interface rate at. I played these files in Quicktime, in Finder and compared between 48kHz and 96kHz when I played this part. (link removed) Hopefully you can take a listen to the 44.1 and 192 to hear what you hear. I may have mentioned it but it's a midi part played through Kontakt. Each time I used the resampling feature in Live (which I think internally records at 32 bit then dithers down) I restarted Live as per Kontakt's direction. Then I just moved the files to my desktop. idk but it sounds different to me.
-----
I removed the link because I like the part I recorded and I don't want to share it. If anyone is interested in this thread maybe I can record a new part for critical listening.
Thanks!
Hi Mr. Winer. Hope you're well. Wondering if you've seen this video about 192kHz sample rates. www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_wxRGiBoJg
Presently I'm unsure of your stance on this but the gentleman brings up an interesting point: timing and distance become the focus above 44.1kHz sampling rather than pitch.
Inspired by you I did a little test on my MOTU ultralite mk3 and, hardware quality notwithstanding, I found a perceptible difference among the sample rates.
I just thought you might appreciate the perspective if you weren't already familiar. Thanks!
PS - if you'd like I can give you a drop box link to my files.
-----
(response follows edited):
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIQ9IXSUzuM
-----
me again:
I've seen that vid and even have shared it. Thanks for pointing out that specific section though. I'm clicking around your forum but the link didn't send me to any thread. I would definitely like to hear what you have to say about sample rates though.
I've seen that vid and even have shared it. Thanks for pointing out that specific section though. I'm clicking around your forum but the link didn't send me to any thread. I would definitely like to hear what you have to say about sample rates though.
All I can say is that listening to these files I recorded there's a difference in sound among the sample rates. This is true regardless of what I set my audio interface rate at. I played these files in Quicktime, in Finder and compared between 48kHz and 96kHz when I played this part. (link removed) Hopefully you can take a listen to the 44.1 and 192 to hear what you hear. I may have mentioned it but it's a midi part played through Kontakt. Each time I used the resampling feature in Live (which I think internally records at 32 bit then dithers down) I restarted Live as per Kontakt's direction. Then I just moved the files to my desktop. idk but it sounds different to me.
-----
I removed the link because I like the part I recorded and I don't want to share it. If anyone is interested in this thread maybe I can record a new part for critical listening.
Thanks!
