|
Post by saxomophone on Aug 12, 2017 18:43:40 GMT
Hello all, I've been meaning to do this since Ethan moved his forum to this site! I'm a slacker...and am therefore just getting around to it. Here is my room. It's 11' wide by 13' deep and has 8' ceilings. I will use it for recording saxophone, vocals, and maybe a little guitar. I'll also use it for mixing. The door is right in the corner of the room, which will make it a challenge to treat that particular corner. That said, I have a few ideas that I think will work. I will likely do super-chunk traps in the three corners that are available. I'll also likely treat the wall to ceiling corners too. My problem is the window which is on one of the 13' walls. In reading through the forum I've seen that it is better to put your desk on the shorter wall so that the back wall is further from your listening position. However, I could also put my desk in front of the window. Either way, my plan would be to build two panels that would be mounted with "barn door" style sliders to treat the windows. That way I could slide each panel to the right and left of the window when I want to see out, but slide them over the window when I'm mixing or recording. Seems so me that it would be easier to treat the room with "balance" in mind at the listening position if the desk were in front of the window. But the rear wall would be closer to me than if I were to put the desk on the 11' wall. So that's my first question...where should I place the desk? Then, what strategy would you choose for treatment based on the desk location? Thanks in advance for any and all comments and recommendations!
|
|
|
Post by Ethan Winer on Aug 14, 2017 19:47:46 GMT
In this case you could face the window even though the speakers then fire down the shorter dimension. The difference between 11 and 13 is small, and that avoids the problem of the window being at a reflection point. There's no reason to put anything absorbing in front of the window that's now in front because your speakers face the other way. Though the rear wall behind you will benefit from being fully treated. With the door behind you, you can treat that corner with panels on the door and adjacent wall like this:
|
|
|
Post by rock on Aug 15, 2017 14:10:42 GMT
I've seen that photo above many times and that of course is a great way to deal with doors in the corner... but I just noticed that it only works (well) if the door swings open "OUT". If the door opens into the room, the thickness of the absorbers might keep the door from opening all the way. In that case though, a moveable absorber could be placed in front of the door. Additionally, if you really want to get fancy, you could mount the "door" absorber on a couple of hinges on the right side of the door (using the above photo as a reference) so you could swing the absorber in and out of the way easily.
Cheers, Rock
|
|
|
Post by Hexspa on Aug 15, 2017 16:22:13 GMT
Or there's always hoping there'll never be a fire like I do Probably not great if you often need the door. Luckily, I'm a hermit.
|
|
|
Post by saxomophone on Aug 17, 2017 10:35:35 GMT
Thanks to all ror the responses.
Ethan, I thought you might give that advice. The window reflectiveness is my concern for sure. There are actually closet doors across from the window, but they will be under treatment anyway.
Rock, great minds think alike! My door does open inwards into the room. I think I have enough clearance to treat the door surface, but I was going the direction of a hinged panel on the right wall that could swing out of the way. The approach would allow that panel to cover the corner on a 45 degree angle, creating an air gap. I'll need to do more measurements to make sure that approach is feasible.
Hexspa, That door looks functional to me...as long as you're on the thin side! That last part is the vexing part for me.😏
|
|